The Honourable Schoolboy by John le Carré

The Circus, hub of Britain’s spymasters, is in disarray. After the discovery of a mole in the previous novel, Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy, the secret service have lost all respect in the eyes of their employers, their enemies and their allies.

The Honourable Schoolboy

It falls to George Smiley, once retired, now returned to action, to rebuild their shattered reputation. Backtracking through old cases, he and his ragtag band of trusted survivors pore over past case files looking for the slip that the mole might have left in covering his tracks. A chance discovery leads them to Drake Ko, a mysterious Hong Kong financier.

The Circus know that something is awry but they don’t know what it is. They are not sure who they are chasing, what evidence they are gathering, or even what interest their Warsaw Pact rivals have in Hong Kong. They are feeling in the dark, following a hunch, which means that this novel has an extraordinarily complicated plot. It is impossible to tell who is on what side, or even who is alive or dead.

Everything comes back to George Smiley, the crumpled, weary, but wiley spymaster, who is pursuing a decades-long vendetta against his Soviet opposite number, codenamed Karla.

Smiley and his colleagues perform ghastly work, where people are mere assets and their own operatives can be left to be tortured or killed with barely a shrug of their shoulders. Yet we feel pity for him.

It must be because Smiley feels completely real. He is one of the great characters of British twentieth century fiction. This is partly brought about through le Carré’s cinematic descriptions:

 ‘Lucca. Yes. Ann and I went there. Oh, eleven, twelve years ago it must have been. It rained.’ He gave a little laugh. In a cramped bay at the further end of the room, Jerry glimpsed a narrow, bony-looking camp bed with a row of telephones at the head. ‘We visited the bagno, I remember,’ Smiley went on. ‘It was the fashionable cure. Lord alone knows what we were curing.’ He attacked the fire again and this time the flames flew alive, daubing the rounded contours of his face with strokes of orange, and making gold pools of his thick spectacles.

Locations also come thrillingly alive, be they remote Chinese beaches, hideaways in the jungles of Laos or the grim streets of London:

the rain was taking a mid-morning pause. On the slate rooftops of Victorian cottages, the dripping chimney pots huddled like bedraggled birds among the television aerials. Behind them, held up by scaffolding, rose the outline of a public housing estate abandoned for want of funds.

Back in 1977, when this book was published, le Carré was often lumped together with vacuous airport novelists. After the Cold War ended, many people imagined that his work had lost all relevance. Yet le Carré is more popular than ever with multiple film treatments of his books in the works.

Le Carré has survived the Fall because his books are not really ‘about’ spying at all. They express the indignation of an honourable man who sees his country and the system he believes in ruthlessly exploiting anyone who gets in their way. His books are about justice and how quickly it is sidelined:

‘…the Company [the CIA] used a few of the northern hilltribes for combat purposes, maybe you knew that. Right up there in Burma, know those parts, the Shans? … Lot of those tribes were one-crop communities, ah, opium communities, and in the interest of the war there, the Company had to, ah, well, turn a blind eye to what we couldn’t change, follow me? These good people had to live and many knew no better and saw nothing wrong in, ah, growing that crop. Follow me?’

His works also explore the peculiar desires that drive people to become deep-cover operatives, like Jerry Westerby, the ‘honourable schoolboy’ of the title. It is a weird profession where decisions of life and death are rewarded not with riches or praise, but with letters that can be read, but never kept, by their recipients.

The Honourable Schoolboy is a great novel which could have won the Booker Prize had it not suffered from the contempt that people used to have for the genre in which le Carré chose to work. However, like the spooks of his story, one feels that he takes quiet satisfaction in a job well done, even if it is performed in the shadows, away from the bright lights of polite society.

You can read a fascinating 2010 interview with le Carré here.


11 responses to “The Honourable Schoolboy by John le Carré

  1. Interesting review and great choice of extracts. I’m a huge fan of the Smiley novels particularly as le Carré slowly, but surely brings to life a deeply fascinating, complex character. Don’t you think that Smiley is the ice in Westerby’s single malt romanticism in this novel? I’ve just finished ‘The Little Drummer Girl’ (1983) again good on place and male characters, but has problematic, unbelievable or stereotypical portrayal of female characters.

    • That’s true. Smiley and Westerby make a fascinating pair. I’d not thought of them before as a kind of contrasting spy types but I now see exactly what you mean.
      It’s also true that this novel is stronger on the male characters than the female ones, but I’ve just started Smiley’s People, which opens with a fascinating encounter with an old lady in Paris, who it seems is some kind of Soviet dissident/ double agent…

  2. Le Carre is notoriously weak on female characters, making it perhaps a good thing that he writes in an area dominated by male ones. For all that though, every writer has failings and he has many strengths as you bring out here Alastair. Smiley is tremendously well realised, and Le Carre can evoke a scene or location like nobody’s business.

    I think he survived the other Airport novelists by just plain being a better writer, though some brilliant TV adaptations didn’t hurt either I’ll admit.

    • I think I’m going to have to find some strong female characters in le Carre books now to defend him, but there were precious few in this one! I would say it was a 1970s affliction, but there were plenty of writers creating strong female characters at the time so that’s no real excuse.
      I think le Carre does so well out of film adaptions because top-flight actors like Alec Guinness and Gary Oldman are attracted to deep, tortured complex characters like his protagonists. But my goodness, the stories have such labyrinthine plots ( a cliche I managed to avoid in my review but there it is!).

      • I think the plots are why it works better on TV than film. I’m not knocking the recent Tinker Tailor here, but it’s just plain easier to squeeze it all in with a television adaptation.

        Good luck finding well realised women in Le Carre! Doesn’t have to be strong, a well written weak woman would be fine. Some authors just struggle with the other gender, it’s weird but it’s a thing.

  3. Excellent review, I will have to read some le Carré which is a gaping hole in my literary knowledge. I do like labyrinthine plots though, what is the first book you would recommend for me.

    • Well I read The Spy Who Came In From the Cold first but it was very dark, and Smiley is only a peripheral figure. I then got into the Karla trilogy which begins with Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy and then continues with this one followed by Smiley’s People. I’m reading the latter now and I’m completely hooked after a handful of chapters. So I’d start with Tinker, especially if you haven’t see the great film with Gary Goldman, because the movie tells you who the mole is.

  4. I always avoid the films unless I didn’t know it was a book. There’s nothing like picking holes in a film after or appreciating what they could do with the limitations that films have. Thanks for the advice, it’s always something to be wary when tackling a new author, the order of books.

  5. How true your comments are about how snobbery about the genre prevents the likes of le carre getting award recognition. No less enjoyable, (or intricate), are the novels of le carre’s 1930s predecessor: Eric Ambler. The ‘mask of dimitrios’ is a shadowy jaunt around 1930s Europe. The book also had the underlying foreboding about upcoming war present in many books written in 1939, like ‘after many a summer dies the swan’, or perhaps the hobbit. By the way, on holiday in a place called Tamariu in Catalonia in late august if you’re about?

    • I know who you are, Admiral! Tamariu is lovely. I went there a couple of years ago and I think I should be able to meet you there. I’ll drop you an email or perhaps send a letter by Clipper that can be dropped on your galley when they cross mid-ocean!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.